Home Architecture News Piers Taylor Argues AI Shows How Narrowly Architects Have Defined Their Value
Architecture NewsArtificial Intelligence

Piers Taylor Argues AI Shows How Narrowly Architects Have Defined Their Value

Architect and educator Piers Taylor argues in Dezeen that defending drawing production against AI is a mistake, and that the profession should be paid for judgement, briefing, post-occupancy work and long-term care of buildings.

Share
Aerial view of a grassy clearing with felled branches, stacks of sawn boards, square timber frames and a group assembling a structure
A Studio in the Woods workshop seen from above, the kind of co-production Taylor describes · Photograph: Jim Stephenson
Share

The debate about architects and AI usually turns on what machines cannot do yet. In an opinion piece for Dezeen’s Performance Review series, published on 29 October, architect and educator Piers Taylor argues that this is the wrong question. “If AI can do most of what we think an architect does, maybe we have defined the profession too narrowly,” he writes. What follows summarises his argument; the views are his.

Against a defensive profession

Taylor, who founded the practice Invisible Studio and convenes the Studio in the Woods workshop, says architects are anxious because AI can already produce images, generate options, draft text and take on more technical production. The predictable reaction, he argues, is to wall off the tasks machines cannot yet do and insist on the architect’s special status, and he calls that “absolutely the wrong response”. In his view the profession has long retreated into authorship as its real control over building has shrunk.

He is blunt about architectural culture. Architects are still trained, he says, to imagine themselves as “mini Corbusiers”, dressing a back extension in rhetoric as if it were Ronchamp. “But the age of the hero is exhausted,” he writes, adding that the profession lacks the cultural authority, economic power or public attention to sustain the fantasy.

A tall curved white rough-rendered wall lit from above, with a small altar, a candle and a cross below
Light falling into a chapel at Le Corbusier’s Notre-Dame-du-Haut in Ronchamp, the building Taylor uses as shorthand for the hero model · Photograph: FrDr, CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Architects and AI: the fee problem

For Taylor the economics are broken too. Architects have accepted low pay, long hours, insecure jobs and unpaid competitions, he argues, partly because recognition was offered in place of money. If the production work that fees depend on gets faster and cheaper, defending the same model will only push fees and salaries lower. “The answer cannot be to produce the same things more efficiently for less money,” he writes; clients must instead learn to pay for a wider idea of architectural value.

He is specific about what that could cover: diagnosing problems and shaping a brief before it hardens, connecting different kinds of expertise, trying ideas out at 1:1, resolving clashes over space, returning to buildings once they are occupied, and helping them adapt and be looked after for decades. Practices, he suggests, should keep relationships with buildings and communities instead of vanishing at practical completion, and be paid “for judgement over time” rather than for production alone.

From author to host

The model he proposes is “less author and more host”: someone who can enter an unresolved situation, work out what the problem is and set a framework in which others contribute. He points to Studio in the Woods, which he has run for 20 years, as an accidental laboratory where experts and non-experts build together and leadership shifts with the task.

Several people guiding a long timber truss down a wooded slope among ferns, one pulling a yellow strap
Participants moving a timber structure through the woods at Studio in the Woods · Photograph: Jim Stephenson

Taylor also notes an irony: for years architects tried to become more machine-like, standardising processes and promising complete information, just as machines became good at exactly that. He does not dismiss drawings, technical knowledge or aesthetic judgement, which he says still matter enormously, but sees them as parts of architectural intelligence rather than its definition. If AI makes the old figure of the architect redundant, he concludes, he is not convinced the profession should grieve.

Share
Written by
Bahattin Duran

Bahattin Duran is an architect and Editor in Chief of illustrarch who also leads learnarchitecture.net, where he writes and oversees content. He holds a Bachelor's Degree in Architecture from Düzce University.

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles
People working at desks and standing at a whiteboard in a bright office with a view over San Francisco hills
Architecture NewsArtificial Intelligence

Ex-Palantir Founders Launch Dream With $17M to Build AI World Models for Buildings

San Francisco start-up Dream has emerged from stealth with a 17 million...

Software screen with a colour-coded 3D building model, a bar chart of element counts by level and the heading Model Overview
Architecture NewsBIM

Chaos Acquires Vyssuals to Bring Live BIM Data Dashboards Into Enscape

Chaos, the company behind Enscape, has acquired Vyssuals, whose live dashboards read...

A modern office building with a curved glass top and a red Unite the Union sign over the entrance, behind trees and railings
Architecture NewsCareer

Architecture Workers’ Union Writes to Practices About Staff’s Right to Join a Union

The Section for Architectural Workers has sent a mailshot to UK practices...

Learn Architecture is a global architecture learning platform and marketplace for content creators.

Subscribe to Our Updates

Enjoy a daily dose of architectural projects, tips, hacks, free downloadble contents and more.

Copyright © Learn Architecture Online. All rights reserved.
Made with ❤️ by learnarchitecture.online

iA Media's Family of Brands