Contractor United Living (South) can carry on with a £7.35m defects claim against architect Hawkins\Brown over the Wenlock Building in Islington, north London, after the High Court refused the practice’s application to have the case struck out. In a judgment dated 3 November 2026, Mr Justice Eyre ruled that an earlier settlement between the two firms did not prevent the new proceedings. The decision is procedural only. It does not find that Hawkins\Brown did anything wrong, and the practice denies liability.
Urban Splash Ordered to Pay £46.5m Towards Fire Safety Repairs at Seven Manchester Blocks
Piers Taylor Argues AI Shows How Narrowly Architects Have Defined Their Value
Ex-Palantir Founders Launch Dream With $17M to Build AI World Models for Buildings
AI Pipeline Cross-Checks Structural Design Documents and Flags 253 DiscrepanciesThe building and the earlier dispute
United Living, formerly United House, converted 50 to 56 and 60 Wharf Road into the Wenlock Building under a design and build contract signed in 2007, with Hawkins\Brown appointed as architect. The nine-storey block, more than 18m tall, was completed in 2009. Its lower floors combine brickwork with timber rainscreen cladding, while the upper floors use a Velfac curtain wall system with window frames and rainscreen panels.
After the Grenfell Tower fire, Workspace, which held the benefit of the contractor’s obligations, brought proceedings against United Living over alleged defects that included combustible insulation, timber cladding and missing cavity barriers and fire stopping. United Living in turn claimed against members of the project team. Its claim against Hawkins\Brown ended in a settlement in March 2023 worth about £1.6m, which, according to Construction Enquirer, expressly left out the cost of repairing the Velfac system.

What the new defects claim covers
The contractor now seeks £3.14m to replace the Velfac facade and windows, citing alleged fire safety and environmental performance defects, plus £4.2m to remedy what it says is inadequate fire protection to the structural steel. It alleges that Hawkins\Brown did not meet its design and inspection responsibilities. Dovista UK, formerly Velfac, and Dantaag are also named as defendants.
Hawkins\Brown argued that the claims had already been settled, that United Living was estopped from bringing them, and that the new case was an abuse of process because the contractor knew a further claim was possible in 2023 but did not raise it. The court heard that United Living had received preliminary expert advice in January 2023 pointing to possible further claims.
Why the judge let it proceed
Mr Justice Eyre found that the agreement settled a defined dispute rather than every claim connected with the project. “The settlement agreement was a settlement of a particular claim and was not a general release,” he said, as quoted by Construction News. He rejected the estoppel argument as insufficiently particularised and concluded that the potential further claim was too undeveloped in 2023 for the later proceedings to be abusive.

A spokesperson for Hawkins\Brown told the AJ the practice was disappointed, would not comment further while proceedings continue, and is “vigorously defending the claim”. Liability for the alleged defects remains disputed and will be decided, if at all, later in the case. For practices, the judgment is a reminder that settlement wording decides what is actually released: an agreement covering a named dispute leaves the door open to claims outside it.
Leave a comment